40 Mccarter Avenue, Fair Haven, NJ 07704

$1,499,000

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 4 Baths: 3 Square Footage: 2,680 Status: Pending

Current Price: $1,499,000 List Date: 3/18/2026 Last Modified: 3/27/2026

Overview

Description

Spacious 4/5 BR home located in the heart of Fair Haven offering the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Main level Family Room with Gas Fireplace opens to the Updated Eat-in Kitchen and Multi-purpose room overlooking the backyard. Second level with 3 BRs and staircase to a 4th spacious BR with private deck. Lower level with optional 5th bedroom or wonderful home office plus bonus room perfect for the home gym or playroom. 3 new Full Baths. Basement is partially finished offering additional rec space and a large storage room. Private yard featuring an inground heated pool and perennial gardens. HW floors, home Generator. Close to top-rated schools, parks, local shops and just a quick drive to the Jersey Shore Beaches and transportation to NYC.

Supplements: Driveway can accomodate 4 Cars and in addition, plenty of street parking. New Tankless Hot Water Heater. Central Air in most of the home with newer mini-splits in top bedroom and basement.

Listing Details MLS# 22606648

Contract Info

Start Showing Date: 2026-03-18
List Price/SqFt: 559.33
Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Sub-Type: Detached
New Construction: No

Location

House Number: 40
Street Name: Mccarter
Street Suffix: Avenue
County: Monmouth
Municipality: Fair Haven (FAI)
Postal City: Fair Haven
State: NJ
Zip Code: 07704
Area/Section: None
Complex/Subdivision: None
Middle School: Knollwood
High School: Rumson-Fair Haven
Other High: Red Bank Cath
Directions: Fair Haven Road to Mccarter

General Property Info

Full Baths: 3
Total Baths: 3
# Level 1 - Baths: Yes
# Level 3 - Baths: 2
Fireplace: Yes
# Fireplaces: Yes
Apx SqFt: 2680
# Levels: 3
Apx Year Built: 1952
Garage: Yes
# Car Garage: Yes
Lot Dimensions: 70 x 140
HOA: No
Pool: Yes
Waterfront: No
Waterview: No
Rooms: 10
Basement: Yes

Tax and Legal

Asmnt - Total: 1270200
Taxes: 18126
Tax Year: 2025

Status Change Info

Under Contract Date: 2026-03-27
Contingent Date: 2026-03-23

Remarks & Misc

Excluded: washer, dryer, Kitchen frig, bedroom curtains, Elfa shelving in top floor bedroom.

More Information

Ownership Type

Fee Simple: Yes

Style

Custom: Yes

Interior

Dec Molding: Yes
First Floor Bedroom: Yes

Showing

Showing Time: Yes

Water/Sewer

Public Sewer: Yes
Public Water: Yes

Basement

Partially Finished: Yes

Cooling

Central Air: Yes
Other: Yes

Water Heater

Natural Gas: Yes

Heating

3+ Zoned Heat: Yes

Exterior

Deck: Yes
Lighting: Yes
Patio: Yes
Swimming: Yes

Garage

Attached: Yes
Direct Access: Yes

Assessment Status

Assessed: Yes

Roof

Shingle: Yes

Pool

Heated: Yes
In Ground: Yes

Rooms

Bedroom: Yes
Den: Yes
Dining Room: Yes
Family Room: Yes
Kitchen: Yes
Office: Yes
Primary Bedroom: Yes
Rec Room: Yes

Bedroom Level

Third: Yes
Fourth: Yes

Den Level

First: Yes

Dining Room Level

Second: Yes

Family Room Level

Second: Yes

Kitchen Level

Second: Yes

Primary Bedroom Level

Third: Yes

Office Level

First: Yes

Rec Room Level

Basement: Yes

Property Features

Ownership Type: Fee Simple Style: Custom Interior: Dec Molding; First Floor Bedroom Basement: Partially Finished Cooling: Central Air; Other Heating: 3+ Zoned Heat Water Heater: Natural Gas Exterior: Deck; Lighting; Patio; Swimming Garage: Attached; Direct Access Roof: Shingle Pool: Heated; In Ground Assessment Status: Assessed Showing: Showing Time Rooms: Bedroom; Den; Dining Room; Family Room; Kitchen; Office; Primary Bedroom; Rec Room Bedroom Level: Third; Fourth Den Level: First Dining Room Level: Second Family Room Level: Second Kitchen Level: Second Primary Bedroom Level: Third Office Level: First Rec Room Level: Basement

Room Information

Room Name	Level
Family Room	Second
Kitchen	Second
Dining Room	Second
Primary Bedroom	Third
Bedroom	Third
Bedroom	Third
Bedroom	Fourth
Den	First
Office	First
Rec Room	Basement

Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Realty

Listing Agent: Kim L Spector

Last Updated: March - 27 - 2026

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of the Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®, and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.